Normal criticism, or harassment? How to tell the difference
One of the cruellest tricks of a bad workplace is that it makes you doubt your own read. Was that harsh feedback just… feedback? Am I being too sensitive? Let's be honest in both directions, because both mistakes cost you: calling ordinary management "harassment" burns your credibility, and calling real harassment "just feedback" keeps you trapped.
What normal (even uncomfortable) management looks like
- It's about the work, not about you as a person. "This report missed the deadline and had three errors" is about output. "You're useless and everyone knows it" is about you.
- It's consistent and fair. The same standard applies to your colleagues, not a special harsher one built for you.
- It comes with a route forward. Real feedback tells you what "better" looks like. Criticism designed to diminish just leaves you smaller.
- Reasonable management is expressly allowed. Setting expectations, correcting work, even discipline — done reasonably — isn't harassment, and the law recognises that.
What tips it into something worse
- It's a course of vexatious conduct — personal, repeated, and known or reasonably known to be unwelcome (the OHSA harassment test).
- It's targeted at a protected ground. If the hostility tracks your race, sex, disability, age or religion, it can be discrimination or human-rights harassment, not just a bad manager.
- The goalposts keep moving. Nothing is ever good enough because being good enough was never the point.
- It follows you speaking up. Criticism that appears right after a complaint can be a reprisal.
The honest test, and what to do
Ask: if a fair colleague saw the full pattern, dated and in context, would they call this reasonable management or something else? Then let evidence, not 3am doubt, answer. Keep a private, dated log for a few weeks. If it fills with personal, targeted, or protected-ground conduct, you're not being too sensitive — and you have routes (your employer's harassment policy; the human-rights tribunal if it's protected-ground). If it turns out to be clumsy-but-fair management, you get your peace back, which is worth a lot too.
You don't have to work this out alone. In My Corner is a team of five AI companions for exactly this — one who listens, one who decodes letters and knows your deadlines, one who keeps your evidence organised, one for fresh starts, one who teaches. Private by design: conversations are never stored on our servers.
Talk it through — In My Corner
In My